Unlikely Pairings in the First Person

A novel set in the seventeenth century, Girl with a Pearl Earring (1999), and a movie, Goodfellas (1990), set in the later part of the twentieth century have something in common. Both have female main characters who narrate the story in the first person . . . great idea for the movie, but not such a great idea for the book.

In general, it is not a good idea to write an entire book in the first person because it limits the scope of the story and, frankly, gets a bit tedious to read after a time. Although the story idea is clever and well-imagined, I fostered a growing dislike of the main character Griet. Therein lies the problem with first person narration–if one doesn’t like the main character, it’s difficult to sustain an interest in the book. However, Girl is so unique in its subject matter, which reveals the inner workings of the Vermeer household from the maid’s viewpoint, that I finished the story.

In contrast, I adore Martin Scorsese’s movie, Goodfellas (1990). Unlike a novel, first person narration works better in a movie, for the visuals offer the viewer a type of third person, omniscient point-of-view. The female narrator (Karen Hill) who tells the inside story of a mafia wife is a sympathetic character. Not quite innocent and not quite naive,  she gives the audience a believable and intimate look at the life of a mob family. Using a female point-of-view to tell a mob story is deliciously ironic.

Girl with a Pearl Earring may soon become a movie. This could be a case of a movie being better than the book that inspired it. Can you  think of any books that worked better on the big screen?

Advertisements

About bedsidereader

I love books, animals, yoga, and writing. Learning new facts and information keeps me feeling alive. For as long as I could read, I have had books at my bedside. I started this blog to share what I read and to find out what others are reading.
This entry was posted in Books, magazines, and literature discussion, opinion, reviews. Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Unlikely Pairings in the First Person

  1. Baltimoretim says:

    Hi, Not better than the book, but just as good. “Gone with the Wind” follow the book as close as any movie can. No matter how fast you read, a movie can never come close. The time factor will not allow.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s